Tarek predicted 5 month ago that Citadel would sue Kalshi.
In this interview from June, @mansourtarek_ explains exactly why stock perps are a big threat to Wall Street.
Now Citadel, CME, Cboe and Nasdaq are suing him to stop Kalshi from offering perps.
Here is why.
1 - THEY FEAR LOSING RETAIL
Citadel executes ~35% of US-listed retail volume and make money by trading against their orders. Stock perps threaten to redirect that activity.
If someone trades an Apple perp on Kalshi instead of Apple shares, Citadel loses.
Their own court filing explicitly admit to it:
- “Cboe and Citadel Securities lose transactions and revenue they cannot later recover.”
- “Kalshi's offering is designed to draw away CME’s customers who currently trade futures.”
2 - PERPS GENERATE LESS FEES
So why wouldn't Citadel just offer Perps themselve ?
Because traditional futures have an expiry date. To keep your exposure you need to close you old position and open a new ones. Those additional transactions generate fees.
Perps don’t expire, removing those fees entirely.
The interview passage where Tarek highlights this Perps over Futures advantage is even cited by CME in the lawsuit.
That's why the Citadel camp is asking to reclassify Perps as security-based swaps:
1) Citadel wins - Perps are SEC regulated, retails can't trade them, they keep trading future on their exchange.
2) Kalshi wins - Perps are CFTC regulated, retail can trade them over more expensive futures, Kalshi receive their order flow.